By David Stauss

Key point: In another enforcement action, the California Privacy Protection Agency fined a retail company for selling and sharing personal information through website tracking technologies without providing an opt-out link, honoring opt-out preference signals, or maintaining working methods for consumers to exercise their privacy rights.

On November 17, 2026, the California Privacy Protection Agency (CalPrivacy) announced two more enforcement actions for violations of the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA). The first, which we wrote about here, involved a $1,550,000 fine against a rental car company. The second, which we discuss in this article, is a $217,987 fine against and clothing and accessories retailer. You can find more information on all consumer data privacy enforcement actions using our enforcement tracker.

As with many prior CCPA enforcement actions, this enforcement action focuses on the CCPA’s right to opt out of sales/shares and, in particular, on whether a business’s opt-out methods actually work. The Stipulated Final Order stresses that the obligation to honor opt-out preference signals is not new; it has been in place since 2020. Continuing a recent trend, CalPrivacy also required the company to agree to regularly test and validate its opt-out and consumer request methods to ensure ongoing compliance with the CCPA.

Below, we first discuss the factual allegations underlying the alleged CCPA violations. We then discuss the settlement terms.

Factual Allegations

According to the Stipulated Final Order, from March 2, 2025, to March 31, 2026, the retail company used online tracking technologies, such as cookies and pixels, on its website to sell and share California residents’ personal information (including unique identifiers and browsing history) with third parties for the purpose of cross-context behavioral advertising. These technologies made personal information available to various AdTech companies and registered data brokers.

Despite engaging in CCPA sales/shares, however, the company did not include a “Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information” link or an alternative opt-out link (e.g., “Your Privacy Choices”) on its website. The company also did not honor opt-out preference signals (e.g., Global Privacy Control). When it received a signal, the company neither stopped sending the consumer’s personal information directly from its servers to AdTech companies nor stopped or restricted the browser-based tracking technologies on its website. CalPrivacy noted that, in online advertising, a failure to honor opt-outs can have a “compounding effect.” Here, each time a California resident who had opted out visited the website, the company sold or shared that consumer’s personal information with at least five AdTech companies. Because each disclosure was a separate prohibited sale/share, each such website visit resulted in at least five CCPA violations.

In addition, the methods for submitting consumer requests listed in the company’s privacy policy did not function properly. Company personnel who answered toll-free calls from California residents did not assist certain consumers in exercising their CCPA rights. The company failed to answer emails from some California residents seeking to exercise their rights. The link to the company’s customer care web page led to a “Page Not Found” error. The company’s privacy policy also instructed California residents to use a “Your Privacy Choices” link to exercise their right to opt out of sales/shares, but that link did not exist. And rather than offering two or more of its own methods for opting out, the privacy policy’s “Interest-Based Advertising” section directed consumers to outside resources, such as government, industry, and AdTech websites.

Settlement

Fine

As noted, the company must pay a $217,987 fine. Notably, the Stipulated Final Order states that CalPrivacy was prepared to seek a multimillion-dollar fine but agreed to the lower amount after reviewing confidential financial information supporting the company’s assertion that it could not pay such a fine.

Injunctive Relief

In addition to paying the fine, the company must cease and desist from engaging in device-based sales and shares of all Californians’ personal information to AdTech companies within 30 days of the effective date of the CalPrivacy Board’s order approving the Stipulated Final Order. The company also must:

  • For three years, audit at least quarterly how effectively it honors opt-out preference signals, for both its server-side sales/shares and its browser-based tracking technologies;
  • Comply with the CCPA’s requirements for methods of submitting consumer requests, including offering easy-to-use opt-out methods with minimal steps, maintaining an opt-out link, implementing an interactive webform for submitting privacy rights requests, and timely complying with opt-out requests;
  • For three years, test and validate its methods for submitting CCPA requests at least quarterly;
  • Maintain an internal review process for new tracking technologies that confirms CCPA-compliant contracts are in place where required and that the technologies are configured to honor opt-outs; and
  • Within 30 days, and annually thereafter for three years, train personnel who handle CCPA requests on the CCPA’s requirements.

The company can resume its device-based sales and shares after it provides CalPrivacy with a written certification, signed under penalty of perjury by an officer or director, that the company has conducted the initial audit, testing, and training required above and put in place a plan to continue to comply with those requirements. If the company provides this certification within 30 days of the effective date, it does not have to stop these sales and shares at all.